If the shelves of retail outlets across the country are any indicator, the holidays shall soon be among us, and then cheer and joy will fill the air. Right now, though, something else is permeating the air. So before the happiness of the holidays can ensue, the very large 2 ton elephant (gold chain wearing, gelled out hair, too much cologne wearing elephant to be exact) that’s sitting in the room needs to be addressed, so we can move on. Such a beast may sound like a description of fantasy, like something that could be found on in the pages of a comic-book, but it is very much a reality or, in this case, reality as seen on television. For all the hate and disdain Staten Island receives from the media industry, the producers of reality TV have always had a fondness in their hearts for the Island. If ever there was a case of unwanted, unhealthy love this would be it. From the Food Network’s Door Knock Dinners through to Bridezillas and Queer Eye for the Straight Guy, almost every major reality TV program of the last ten years has made its way to our little rock. The most heinous offender, though, without a doubt, is MTV. They were the first and the worst of Staten Island’s affairs with such shows. Reality TV, though, is not the problem, it’s not what hurts here; it merely brings to light the true issue. A truth that Islanders hate to admit to themselves: yes folks, “The Situation” is real. There, it’s been said, and it can’t be taken back. The most (in)famous stereotype in the history of the genre is quite real and is home grown right here on the Shores of Staten—not Jersey.
When MTV first came to the Island twenty years ago, it seemed like an honor. They were still cool and hip; they focused on all things that had to do with music. That is what the “M” stood for in their name, after all. They had this neat new little show called aptly enough, The Real World, about a bunch of kids from around the country, living together in New York City for a spell. In an early episode the group came to the Island to visit The Red Spot, a nightclub on the North Shore. It seemed like a real feather in the Island’s cap, at the time, to have one of our music venues featured on television. If only we knew then what we know now about the monster that reality TV would become, then we could have slain it then before it was too late. But we didn’t and it did grow beyond all imagining. Fifteen then twenty years later, MTV would return to the scene of the crime, to our Island, to reveal an ugly truth that no one likes to admit to. Once again, despite the disdain and criticism thrown at the exploitive nature of reality TV industry, it is not their fault in this case. Staten Island has no one else to blame but itself for the contributions it made to MTV’s True Life: I’m a Staten Island Girl and The Jersey Shore.
Both the one off episode of True Life and the entire series run of Jersey Shore present a unique type of individual indigenous to Staten Island. There have been many descriptive names slung at this class of human being, usually and unfairly linking Italian heritage to the archetype. This is a misnomer, though, and Italians, who along with Greeks gave us the foundation for modern civilization, should not be looked upon as the genesis for such Islanders. No, this is a personality, a culture that was sown, nurtured and brought to blossom right here on the Island. The standard fare of stereotypical nomenclatures must therefore be avoided to protect the innocent. A new name must be given to this subspecies of Staten Islander. Perhaps the “Gold Breasted Dunsel” would be an apt name for this type of Islander. The gold breasted would refer to the extreme tans of such persons and/or to the preference to always be clad in shiny gold chains. Dunsel, a variation of dunce, is self-explanatory; as there is obviously something restricting the flow of blood to their brains (could be the gold chains). It is also a term from science fiction that means a person or thing of no real use, which is also quite true of the type. Now that we have a proper name for them, we can avoid the use of the more colorful, derogatory terms typically used when discussing the ilk, which would reside on the Jersey Shore (despite New Jersey’s Governor Christie statements to the contrary), Brooklyn and most especially Staten Island.
The Gold Breasted Dunsel (GBD) is a rather interesting cultural species. While there is no formal date of their creation, an educated guess of 1965 can be posed. In 1965, the maniacal urban planner, Robert Moses, completed construction of the Verrazano Bridge directly connecting Staten Island with the rest of New York City (through Brooklyn) for the first time in its history. By default, it also gave Brooklyn and New Jersey (to which the Island was already connected by three other bridges) more immediate access to one another with Staten Island serving as the central location. The Verrazano created a new migration pattern where immigrants and working class would move from Brooklyn to Staten Island and finally, New Jersey. Theoretically the mixing of classes and cultures between Brooklyn and New Jersey on the Island could have resulted in a new culture evolving (a term used with great hesitation). Despite the generalization that the GBD are of Italian heritage, the truth is a GBD can be of any ethnic or cultural ancestry; they simply need the right conditions to gestate. These conditions include, but not limited to, growing up in a neighborhood already infested by GBDs, having parents who lied to them as children by telling them things like that they are the center of the universe and the world revolves around them, having family that doesn’t push them out of the nest but instead allows them to live at home well into adulthood (though they are not the only subculture to suffer from this), too much media exposure to the mobster lifestyle (both fictional and in the news), and being in a close vicinity to dance halls and/or night clubs (typically disco or more recently hip-hop).
A GBD can easily be identified from the rest of humanity by clothing choices, language patterns, musical taste, hangouts, levels of alcoholic consumption and skin tone (though not in the way that you think). Though there are obvious variances with each generation, fashion has always been a major component. The basics for male GBDs typically consist of the most trendy and expensive sneaker of the moment, standard T-Shirts or Muscle T-Shirts (sometimes disappointingly referred to as wife-beaters), Track Suits and partially unbuttoned dress shirts, as GBD males are often gym fanatics and enjoy showing off their upper physique. They also like to accentuate their bodies with solid gold plated drapings, usually in the form of a hearing bone chain, saint medallion or crucifix. GBD females have always been fond of high heeled shoes or boots, incredibly tight form-fitting clothing, gaudy earrings and, more recently, naval piercings, as well as G-String underwear that can be exposed from the rear for public view. Brand names are very important to the GBD and a few examples through the ages are PUMA, Jordache, Kamikaze, Cavaricci, Tommy Hilfiger, Ed Hardy, Gucci, and Juicy Couture. Their language patterns are always on the cutting edge of last year’s slang. Proper English has always been an alien concept to them. Males will often revert to more primal grunts while females will emit a high pitch squeal. Music for the GBD has had somewhat of a paradigm shift over the last thirty to forty years of their known existence. Early on, disco produced the mating songs of the GBD, and while the modern version of said music is still a familiar fallback, Hip-Hop has become the more dominant music in the lives of many GBDs. Whether or not they actually understand any of the serious overtones of inner-city Black American life that embodies the spirit of Hip-Hop remains to be seen. Most likely, they simply enjoy the large pounding beats of the music. Their territorial hangouts usually revolve around the gym for the males and suburban malls for the females, along with the many community feasts during the winter months. A somewhat nocturnal group, they will often frequent loud nightclubs, bars and dance halls throughout the year. In the summer season, however, most GBDs migrate to the geographical shore of New Jersey in such areas as Seaside Heights and Wildwood Beach. It is during this period of time that the mating rituals for the GBDs increase to astronomical heights, along with their consumption of alcohol. GBDs enjoy alcohol above all other things except themselves and will often binge drink to a degree that would put a Roman Emperor to shame. Throughout the year they also partake in a strange ritual where by, through so-called tanning salons, they change the color of their skin to orange. It is believed that they are, in fact, trying to achieve the bronze look of natural tanning but the artificial process somehow leads them astray.
While upon initial description GBDs may sound like simple clowns (though circus clowns may take offense to the comparison), they however carry with them a darker history as well. Perhaps, in part, due to that fact that they were raised to believe that they as individuals are more important then anyone else in the world. This misconception has lead to an arrogance that promotes violent behavior. Both sexes of the species will often behave in a primitively aggressive manner when at their night dwellings, malls and gyms. Whether it is battles with one another to determine the alpha of the group or the belief that all traffic on the road everywhere in the world will yield to them since they’re in a rush to get to the nail salon or vitamin store, they put normal, everyday people into jeopardy. Additionally, there has always been a tendency to act with prejudice towards other cultures or sometimes whole races. Past generations had a particular distaste for Black Americans; though this particular hatred seems to a petered off over the last two generations. Currently the LGBT and Islamic communities seem to be focus of aggression from some, though not all, of the GBD community.
Unfortunately, everything viewers have seen on True Life: I’m a Staten Island Girl and The Jersey Shore, in regards to GBDs is quite real. It can not be denied that Jolie, Vinny and The Situation are homegrown. While GBD’s can live in other areas of New York City and throughout New Jersey, Staten Island is most definitely the heart of this culture. The false impression, in this case, is that they represent Staten Island as a whole. Yes, they are a strong presence here on the Island. They are not, however, the majority culture. In fact, it is safe to say that no culture or subculture has any more dominance over the Island then any other. It would be fair to say, though, that all Islanders do suffer from the fact that these few personalities have dominated the media in recent years and given the misapprehension that they are the face of Staten Island. Really they’re nothing more then just the loudest voice in the crowd. Islanders have a long way to go if they ever want to rescue their reputation which now lies in tatters against the rocks along the Jersey Shore. To move forward, though, first requires that the Island admits the truth to itself. Yes, Gold Breasted Dunsels are part of our identity, but at least we can say the Snookie isn’t from here.
By S. Elliot Fisher